Benjamin is nine years old. He lives in Red Wing, Minnesota with his parents and three siblings. Ben has quadriplegia and cerebral palsy and lives with occasional seizures and major reflux issues.

Ben’s mother, Carrie Quade, recently made a request to the family’s health plan for an enclosed hospital bed, recommended by Ben’s physician. The bed has head elevation to treat reflux and a hi/lo feature so his parents can help with self-care at an ergonomically friendly height to prevent injuries and back problems.

Request Denied

The health plan denied the request. One person Quade spoke with suggested that Ben could sleep on a mattress on the floor.

“I got really upset when they said that,” says Quade. “Ben is getting too big, and I’d never be able to get him off the floor. Besides, I’m not going to have my kid sleep on the floor. That’s just mean.”

Quade appealed the health plan’s decision to deny the bed, and her appeal was also denied. She then turned to Legal Aid’s Minnesota Disability Law Center. Staff Attorney Jennifer Giesen, who has 20 years of experience advocating for clients with disabilities in assistive technology disputes, took the case.

Attorney Helps to Make the Case

“I thought they had a very solid case,” says Giesen. “Carrie’s not a lawyer by training, but she is the expert on her son and his needs. My role is to figure out what the health plan is obligated to cover, work with the family and the medical team on their expectations, and match everything up so the child can get the assistive technology he needs.”

A bed with head elevation was clearly necessary to prevent choking from reflux, and leg elevation would keep him from sliding down during the night. Also, because Ben has occasional seizures, side rails and a properly fitting mattress were required for a safe sleep environment. Entrapment between a bed mattress and railings is a serious issue for people with disabilities like Ben, who has some mobility but limited motor control.

“Jennifer was amazing from the start,” Quade says. “She helped me relax about the whole thing. She said, ‘Don’t worry Carrie, we’re going to get this.’ She couldn’t give a 100% guarantee, but she was pretty sure.”

Getting Everyone on the Same Page

Giesen helped Quade and Ben’s medical team to understand exactly what the health plan was likely to cover and what they would not. She put together a new request for a bed with the exact features required by Ben’s medical condition.

“As attorneys, we sometimes have to clarify things for the health plan,” says Giesen. “The letter of medical necessity in support of the bed was written with a therapeutic justification. As a lawyer, I look at it from the legal justification. I understand the health plan’s obligations, and my job is to help them see how the letter of medical necessity meets the coverage criteria that they are obligated to follow.”

A Favorable Result

When the health plan received Giesen’s letter, they approved the enclosed bed as requested. Quade was delighted that the case settled without having to go to court. Given Ben’s medical condition, especially his risk of choking, having a new bed as quickly as possible was important for his safety.

“Jennifer really knew what she was doing,” says Quade. “I’m a working mother with four kids, and I don’t have the money to go out and hire a lawyer. I’m pretty savvy, and maybe I could have eventually gotten a bed for Ben on my own, but it would have taken a long time. It’s great to have someone like Jennifer on your side.”

Share
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

More Stories

Raids on Encampments Spawn Class Action Lawsuit

Public parks were the best housing option for many unhoused people in the Twin Cities in 2020. Even when space in public shelters was available — which was rare — they were a hazardous option in a pandemic. More than 300 of the 3000+ unhoused people in the Twin Cities...

Read More

REACH JUSTICE MINNESOTA

Justice Buses bring on-the-spot legal help to neighborhoods across Minnesota.

Legal Aid is bringing attorneys and Wi-Fi-enabled legal resources to people in remote locations who otherwise would not have access to these services. Learn how Justice Buses are providing on-the-spot legal help to people in 20 Minnesota counties – one stop at a time. ...

Watch Video

Legal Services Advocacy Project

Making school lunch shaming a thing of the past

The first reports of “lunch shaming” in Minnesota came to Legal Aid’s Legal Services Advocacy Project (LSAP) back in 2008. School cafeteria workers were publicly dumping students’ lunches in the garbage or serving alternative meals because their parents hadn’t paid the bill. Much has changed since then, including Minnesota’s 201...

Read More